Spooky Skyr Dirt Cups

Get ready to dig into a spooky treat that’s as fun as it is nourishing! These Spooky Skyr Dirt Cups put a high-protein twist on the classic childhood favorite. Made with creamy skyr, this dessert comes in chocolate, vanilla, or a swirly mix of both, layered with chocolate cookie “dirt” and topped with wiggly gummy worms for that perfectly creepy-crawly touch!

Spooky Skyr Dirt Cups

Arch background

Arch background

Whatcha Need

1 (24 oz) tub of Painterland Sisters Plain Skyr Yogurt
1 (24 oz) oz tub of Painterland Sisters Vanilla Skyr Yogurt
4 Tbsp cocoa powder
4 Tbsp coconut sugar or other sweetener alternative
About 30 chocolate sandwich cookies, crushed into crumbs (such as the Goodie Girl brand, two boxes)
One bag of gummy worms (such as the Black Forest brand)

Servings: 8 (~5 oz) cups

Whatcha Do

In a medium mixing bowl, combine the Plain skyr yogurt, cocoa powder, and coconut sugar. Mix well until smooth and creamy.
In your parfait cups, add a layer of the yogurt mixture (about 2 Tbsp), followed by a layer of cookie crumbs (about 1 Tbsp). Add another layer of yogurt (about 3 Tbsp), then finish with a sprinkle of cookie crumbs. Top with gummy worms as desired.
Repeat the process until all your parfait cups are full. You can make them entirely chocolate, entirely Vanilla Bean, or a mix of both! Serve immediately.

(If Vanilla Bean only, skip step #1.)
Tip: The longer the cookie crumbs sit with the yogurt, the softer they will become. If you want to keep them crunchy, wait to assemble the layers until right before serving.

Spooky Skyr Dirt Cups

Servings

8 (~5 oz) cups

Each bite is silky, chocolatey, and delightfully eerie! Whether you’re making it for a costume party, classroom snack, or just a frightfully fun family dessert, this playful recipe will have kids and adults of all ages coming back for seconds.

So grab your spoons—it’s time to dig up some delicious, protein-packed fun!

Image of Spooky Skyr Dirt Cups

Ingredients

1 (24 oz) tub of Painterland Sisters Plain Skyr Yogurt
1 (24 oz) oz tub of Painterland Sisters Vanilla Skyr Yogurt
4 Tbsp cocoa powder
4 Tbsp coconut sugar or other sweetener alternative
About 30 chocolate sandwich cookies, crushed into crumbs (such as the Goodie Girl brand, two boxes)
One bag of gummy worms (such as the Black Forest brand)

Directions

In a medium mixing bowl, combine the Plain skyr yogurt, cocoa powder, and coconut sugar. Mix well until smooth and creamy.
In your parfait cups, add a layer of the yogurt mixture (about 2 Tbsp), followed by a layer of cookie crumbs (about 1 Tbsp). Add another layer of yogurt (about 3 Tbsp), then finish with a sprinkle of cookie crumbs. Top with gummy worms as desired.
Repeat the process until all your parfait cups are full. You can make them entirely chocolate, entirely Vanilla Bean, or a mix of both! Serve immediately.

(If Vanilla Bean only, skip step #1.)
Tip: The longer the cookie crumbs sit with the yogurt, the softer they will become. If you want to keep them crunchy, wait to assemble the layers until right before serving.

plain

Sugar Cookie Yogurt Dip with Homemade Sprinkles

This Sugar Cookie Yogurt Dip is a cheerful holiday treat that’s as fun to make as it is to eat. With homemade sprinkles and a creamy, protein-rich base, it’s a sweet way to bring everyone together.

Get Cookin'
plain

Painter Family Favorite Raspberry Cheesecake

This cherished Painter family cheesecake is everything a holiday dessert should be—simple, comforting, and made with ingredients that feel like home. A velvety skyr-infused cheesecake base pairs with a cool, lightly sweet cream layer and a bright, tart raspberry compote on top. Each slice balances richness and freshness, tradition and creativity, making it a standout for any gathering or cozy moment at home.

Get Cookin'
vanilla bean

High Protein Pumpkin Spice Skyr Cheesecake Bars

Bring the farm-to-spoon goodness to your holiday table! These Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake Bars made with Painterland Sisters yogurt are creamy, cozy, and full of fall flavor! Aka the perfect feel-good treat for Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving!

Get Cookin'
plain, vanilla bean

Autumn Yogurt Dip Flight

Fall is bursting with cozy flavors, and this yogurt dip flight brings them all together in one colorful, crowd-pleasing spread. From Pumpkin Spice to Cranberry Walnut, each creamy skyr dip is simple to make, fun to share, and the perfect way to sweeten any gathering—or a cozy afternoon snack.

Get Cookin'
vanilla bean

Bananas Foster Parfaits

Back-to-school season calls for snacks that are both fun and fueling—and these Bananas Foster Parfaits check all the boxes! Deliciously creamy and high in protein, they pack a tasty punch that keeps kids (and grown-ups!) energized through homework time or after school activities.

Get Cookin'
meadow berry

Swirled Honey Berries + Skyr Popsicles

Snack time just got an upgrade! These honey, berry and skyr popsicles are creamy, protein-packed, and oh-so-refreshing. Perfect for savoring summer’s last rays and powering through after-school cravings.

Get Cookin'

Illustration of a row of flowers

Illustration of a row of flowers